20d vs 30d silpoly polyester ripstop (SilPoly). Silpoly fly appears to have a few wrinkles. There's one more reason why some manufacturer's stay away from polyester: the specter of color transfer. 7 oz less. It sounds like durability is one of your main questions. Available in green or brown in either 20d polyester or 30d nylon, or in 30d polyester Bushwack camo for this ultralight tarp. " I don't think so. poncho, 108″ x 59″. 20d 1. Silpoly textiles are extensively used in the industry for waterproof tarps and tents. The newest Pro 20d is so good we are very comfortable building anything from it except the larger Mids. 15D membrane (0. Above those are 20D poly vs. The regular Haven Tent uses 70D as the body and 20D for the fly, the light version that is. Pads seem to range from 20D to 70D. Cela reste peu sensible si la toile était bien tendue dès le départ. Posted by u/Ernie_McCrackenX - 5 votes and 9 comments 100% recycled 20D silpoly in micro ripstop weave. It's definitely thin but I've had zero issues with durability over the course of about 5 years now. Change le silpoly 30D de la toile extérieure pour le silnylon 20D (excellent rapport résistance/poids). 20D and 30D silnylons can be had from 5 or 6 sources. Mar 30, 2018 · is there a way to tell? it's a superfly, so i'm assuming silnylon or silpoly, as they're the only two listed on site now. 35 osy, current 30d silnylon is 1. My plan is to get an 11 foot Superfly. Extremely interesting experimentation. With the strength and increased abrasion resistance of the 20Dx50D construction, I am thinking a version with HH up around 3000-3500 mm would make a great floor option. Show Printable Version; 02-22-2017, 23:04 #1. 9oz silnylon [excellent but heavier], the standard cheap silnylon 20D [OK], the 15D silnylon [ too light for a mountain hunt], the 1. specializing in high quality gear for the outdoor enthusiast; menu; hammocks Ok at this point people are going to stop reading my threads because I'm clearly insane. That was never a deal breaker, but would be nice to reduce/eliminate. He put 2 strictly identical shelters, one in 20D silnylon, the other in 30D silpoly in a continuous rain of 6H. Custom Mountainfly Builder × 1 $170. 50 per yard. Finished weight would be around 1. Second, it seemed to mist thru very fine. I assume this is related either to weight and/or thickness. Warbonnet has so many more choices now – I might go for a 20D Silpoly Minifly if I was starting off, but I wouldn’t trade out the Hammock Gear tarp for it. Warbonnet says the silpoly stretches less than the nylon but, the silnylon is more durable. Dans de nombreux tests, c'est au niveau de cette trame ripstop que les gouttes apparaissent. You don't have to baby it, I'm just a little mindful of abrasion points when setting it up (which you should do anyway). Polyester or nylon? Also, one of the specs is 20d or 30d. 30D Silnylon-2 ridgeline tieouts; 4 main ground corner tieouts; 4 door tieouts; 4 panel pull tieouts (30d only) Stuff sac; 7g tube of silicone for seam sealing (panel pull versions only) (2) Micro Carabiners for door management; 20D Silpoly-2 ridgeline tieouts; 4 main ground corner tieouts; PANEL PULLS NOT INCLUDED; 4 panel pull tieouts (30d Jan 29, 2016 · If we make this assumption, there’s convincing evidence that a well-designed 20d silpoly shelter should be plenty strong enough for above-the-treeline use. First, it didn't seem the shed the water like the nylon tarps I've used for years. Mar 10, 2022 · If 20D silpoly is enough how come almost all tent makers use thicker fabrics. Be sure to check out the extra options and modifications available in our Custom Tarp Builder section. Bear in mind, the weight of an ILC will change based on the lens you are using during that time. 6 can be sourced at RSBTR and Rockywoods carries a 7D Sil one side and PU the other. Probably the reverse. 5oz for 40d. Sewn in the USA by Warbonnet. As a quick anecdote, Tipik charges a premium if you want to your tent made of 15D or 20D poly rather than 40D nylon. My Tipik Pioulou XL has a much thicker floor. Both fabrics have a minimum 2000mm h2o rating. I suspect it has to do with how much pigment you need to have on the fabric for it to have the appropriate color. The 20D silpoly feels thinner than the 30D silnylon and I don't like the noise it makes. Apr 16, 2022 · Ah, yeah, I don’t think anything comparable to MLD’s 20d silnylon can be found for DIY. 4 oz/sq/yd, a weight comparable with 30D silnylons. 6 Sil-PU3000. I think the 30d also frayed a bit more than the 20d. Yes, I bought another tarp! I love my Mamajamba and it's gotten me thru EVERYTHING over the past 5 years. This would mean that silpoly is a bit more waterproof (I. Having a poly version of my favorite tarp might prove to be just perfect with less sagging when wet. Oct 26, 2020 · – truly extreme weather was a concern – the notch’s 30d silnylon should be tougher than the 20d silpoly – the price was right-weight was a premium – i think the current notch is an oz or so lighter than the x-mid. Feb 6, 2021 · Obviously, if one or the other fabric needs replaced more often, that might more than offset any differences in production. Both of them pack down small, are cheap, and need seam sealing. sil vs PU) make a bigger difference for strength than the fiber type. SilPoly. Considering size and weight, the portability rating of the 20D and 30D is 59 and 58 respectively. For their marketing and customer, tents made from 20D polyesters are far too difficult and too expensive to sell. Poly is nice since it doesn't sag as much when wet or hold water like the nylon. Apr 26, 2025 · Home » Shop » Fabrics by type » Coated » 20D silpoly PU 4000 by 10cm increments. We utilize siliconized 20D ripstop polyester in the flys of our polyester tents. 4 oz finished). 1 oz/yd 2 prior to coating (about 1. I'm well aware that the 70D is twice as heavy as 30D silnylon. 1 oz. It definitely does not grow much when wet, and consequently does not need re-tightening. 8 ounces For sale in either polyester or silpoly camouflage fabric at Warbonnet Outdoors. 19 oz. There are some quality reasons why you should have a tent made from SilPoly which include some of the below: Lower Price Available in green or brown in either 20d polyester or 30d nylon, or in 30d polyester Bushwack camo. vs. I think I’m going to go with 20D 1. シルナイロン20d & シルポリ20d の1m単位の生地販売です。国内ではあまり流通していない20デニールのリップストップ・ファブリックです。シルナイロン＆シルポリを選ぶ時は（糸の太さ）だけでなくリップストップも重要な要素です。ULシェルターの制作現場ではデニールだけではなく、リップ Silpoly in the extra wide configuration. It's used both for our rainflys and floors. Benefits of SilPoly Tents. 9oz 20D 2000mm NeverMist™ Silpoly: 13. I heard Yama uses RSBTR 20D silpoly for their tarps but I haven’t confirmed it. I knew they had a 20D Bushwack but it was only DWR treated and was used for quilts and the like and the 2000mm fabric was 30D with the 20D silpoly only being available in solid colors. Er stellte zwei völlig identische Unterkünfte, eine aus Silnylon 20D, die andere aus Silpoly 30D, unter einen 6-stündigen Dauerregen. 4: Some 20d silnylon stretches way less than some 20d silpoly, even when wet. It is less tear resistant than silnylon. RSBTR recommends gluing the patches on with silicone instead when using membrane silpoly. However, I noticed that Backcountry has the 7oz 30d Rab Siltarp1 Shelter for $63. I doubt anyone is choosing to use a 20-30D poly because it's lower cost. 100% recycled 20D silpoly in micro ripstop weave. Static V2 hybrid: 70d bottom/30d top: 19oz. 4oz 30D 2000mm NeverMist™ Silpoly: 14. Like you, I’ve also weighed the nylon vs polyester in terms of the sagging factor of nylon when humidity rises and temp drops. [Or the 30d Mountain fabric from RSBTR] 30D 2000mm NeverMist™ Silnylon: 14. There is a bit of truth to both of those but it is minimal. 3 oz/yard coated weight), but about 30% weaker (in terms of tear strength). Whether you're an avid backpacker, camper, or outdoor enthusiast, choosing Jun 27, 2014 · A comparison of the wet performance of polyester and nylon rainflies on the same tent. However, for the low weight penalty of 1. He weighed the canvases after shaking and putting them away. Silnylon absorbs moisture which causes the material to relax, so it looses tautness after setup. Both are on sale until tomorrow for If you are still talking Warbonnet tarps, the 30D is camo only. My wondering is that 30D might be worth the weight penalty, as silpoly is already more vulnerable than silnylon of equal weight/denier. 4oz which is the listed weight of their 20D silpoly Thunderfly. Thanks in advance for weighing in. I tested several fabrics about 15 years ago (silnylon,polyhester,Epic and early GoreTex(Bibler Todd Tex) from memory the worst was about a 60% weight gain on Epic , from memory silnylon (30d 1500mm WH) gained around 40%. We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Available in our 20d and 30d SilPoly I'm about to order a Superfly from Warbonnet and before I bug Brandon I thought I would ask all of you. But on our Ridgerunner bridge hammock, there is no ridgeline, and the hammock is usually hung a little flatter, so you can get a 13′ ultralight tarp shelter to come down for sufficient side coverage. HH~2000mm; Width: 147cm; Weight: 41-42 g/m² Jun 5, 2023 · MLD Supertarp is no doubt supreme in terms of material and build. Silpoly Solo Tarp: These are our solo tarps made from lightweight 100% waterproof silpoly fabric. P . The difference in denier will make more of a difference in strength then nylon vs poly. I have used the 30d calendared 1. First, this isn't about the weight of the stuff. 8 ounces lighter than the most recent version of the 30d silnylon fly. 185T polyester is another similar fabric used in tents and many other of the same purposes as 190T and everything you read here about 190T will generally also count for 185T polyester as well. Green tea, charcoal grey, moroccan blue and coyote brown colors. Compared to silnylon it has lower water absorption, less stretch/sag, better UV protection. **Panel Pulls not included with 20D Silpoly fabric. I understand the effect of strength for PU coating vs silicone coating, that reinforces my opinion to stay with silicone coating. Jan 10, 2020 · Silpoly Vs. 6 Nylon, which may shorten the products usable lifespan. 4-1. Fabric. Silnylon vs. Feb 15, 2021 · For 10D fabric the math is that 30D has 3x the linear mass density of 10D and the graphic below would show that the radius of the 10D fabric is 0. - Size is 70"x108" (5. Tarptent for example now use 20D silpoly for some of their fly sheets like the Xmid but have declined to use it for the floor preferring to stick to 30D silnylon. Researched the r/Ultralight and found the 8oz 20d Borah tarp for $61 is a popular budget-friendly option. 2 osy. -I wanted a solid inner . Looking for something slightly lighter/smaller? Check out our MiniFly or ThunderFly tarp models for a downsized version of the MountainFly. Warbonnet Outdoors' Superfly is our most popular winter hammock tarp with doors. It made for year-round weather and is great for wind-proofing your hammock system. Sep 2, 2018 · Hello, I'm looking at the Warbonnet Cloudburst tarp, have a quick question. Feb 25, 2024 · A 20D thread weighs 20 grams per 9000 meters whereas a 75D thread weighs 75 grams per 9000 meters of thread. Colors: Dark olive, Charcoal grey; HH~2000mm; Width: 148cm; Weight: 42-43 g/m² Mar 29, 2019 · For materials, you can choose between UGQ’s 2nd generation 20D Silpoly ripstop or their new 15D Silpoly Membrane fabric. - Smaller vestibules Le silpoly 20D avec trame ripstop 50D donne des résultats assez mauvais (il n'est plus en vente d'ailleurs), tandis que le silpoly 15D sans trame ripstop est plutôt bon. Nov 23, 2019 · This poly vs nylon debate gets all the attention, but it's a bit of a distraction because ultimately both materials work, and also other factors like denier (e. QUOTE] Xenon definitely rates higher than the 1000 Dutch lists, he is just being conservative as usual. 6 nylon fabrics; however, for use on a tent wall do not see a problem. I have tried searching and have only found little information regarding the durability of 15D silpoly tarps. Silpoly doesn't soak up much water and has solid UV resistance. I get that the 20D Silpoly is lighter, is the 30D silnylon more durable? 1. 9oz Ridgeline Length: 11. The sil/pu coating adds weight if I understand it correctly. 30D nylon. High stress tends to grind sand into the interior sides of the slider instead of giving the malleable teeth the opportunity to bend around the grains. There seems to be plenty of people having no issues with 20D, but have not seen many testify to the durability of 15D. I don't have a table big enough, so I'm doing this on a tile floor, which makes the material even more slippery. It doesn't seem to hold as much water either. On the topic of strength to weight, there are many formulations of nylon (e. Is the Rab tarp too small? Are there other budget options to consider? Should I wait till black friday? Apr 6, 2025 · The 20d silpoly is an excellent material for the fly, resisting UV degradation better than classic silnylon, while the 30d silnylon floor offers exceptional puncture and abrasion resistance. Jul 28, 2015 · Weights for 4 meters of fabric are 7. So, on an 11′ end-gathered style hammock, an 11′ ultralight tarp shelter will give more coverage down low than 13′ would. Jan 15, 2023 · A version with the 30D silpoly fly and a 20D silpoly sil/PU floor weighing 21. Jul 31, 2017 · Qualitatively I can say that the tear strength alone is absolutely uncanny compared to similar weight materials, including our own 20D silnylon and silpoly. Silnylon is more tear resistant than silpoly and exists in larger selection of fabrics. Silpoly XL. Not really a weight thing being only about 1oz lighter. Most silpoly shelters and tarps that you find are some type of 20D. Same silpoly benefits of lower water absorption and increased UV resistance compared to Jul 22, 2024 · FWIW, I have had Shelters made from various Silnylon. Because of characteristics very suitable for lightweight tarps, tents, pack covers and other rain gear. I recently purchased a dcf tarp and the camo one there was heavier as well. Packa (not designed as a tarp) comes in 10D, 20D (standard), and 30D silnylon. 1 oz Silpoly and ultralight MEMBRANE Silpoly. Materiały dobrej jakości w dobrych cenach. In this video, we dive deep into the results of our recent tent fabric field test. The 20D silpoly does not come in camo. Overall, the best all purpose materials (in my opinion) are either plain 1. For sure DCF isn't a very puncture resistant material, but the same could be said for 15d or 20d silpoly. 1 osy nylon from Ripstop by the Roll. Silnylon 20D: Vert Olive: Cliquez ici: Si vous souhaitez une couleur différente de celle en stock, cochez la case "couleur May 11, 2023 · Interesting Roger that you say a tunnel tent doesn’t need the no-sag-when-wet silpoly due to its shape… never thought about that so far, I merely was annoyed by all dome tents and tarps I’ve had that sagged. 6oz silpoly [durable, good but heavier] and the higher quality Silnylon 30D which I consider the best all around fabric for the smaller 2-4 man shelters. Oct 19, 2024 · SilPoly Tent Material. 20D silpoly in ripstop weave. 3 osy, and current 20d silpoly is right at 1. The 20d silpoly is a lighter polyester fabric that offers slight weight savings and less water absorption (both fabrics are fully waterproof, but both will absorb some water weight, with the silpoly absorbing less water weight than the silnylon in wet conditions. I use a WB Blackbird XLC. Sep 15, 2020 · Fabric Options: 30D Silnylon or 20D Silpoly (11 feet), 30D Silnylon (13 feet) Panel Pulls are an additional option for 30D Silnylon fabric; Colors: Dark Green, Evergreen, Brown, Fern Green, Grey, Autumn Orange, Ocean Blue, True Blue, Purple, and Bushwhack Camo; My Specs Thunderfly closed. Below is a front view size comparison of the 20D vs the 30D. The Borah tarp is 70x108 and the Rab tarp is 60x90. Some of our SilPoly fabrics are made from recycled content. You can get silpoly that is 90% as strong as the same weight of nylon, where since nylon loses 10% strength when wet the poly can be just as strong in the field on day #1, and then the nylon further weakens over time from greater UV degradation. 55 oz vs 30. 8oz Width: 103” Nov 10, 2023 · Habe das auf jeden Fall mal mit dem 30d Silpoly von Extremtextil und dem 20d Silpoly von adventurexpert ausprobiert (nur eine Messung). 8oz for 20d vs 11. Any insight? Suggestions from people in the know would be helpful, as usual. Jun 2, 2023 · "I know that Silnylon can absorb up to 300% of its weight in water, while Silpoly doesn't absorb any. This fabric is coated with a silicone/PU layer on each side and is waterproof/non-breathable. I’d go x-mid if A light fabric made for clothing like the Taffeta 190T polyester weighs around 56g per square meter of fabric if not too densely woven. Silnylon is definitely stronger when new than silpoly. My idea is that the floor will be 210D or 70D ripstop nylon and the fly 30D or even 20D (don't know yet). The Notch comes in a stealthier green color now as well. Unfortunately though it looks like the only options currently in stock are the 30D silnylon with panel pulls and the 20D silpoly without panel pulls. Would it be correct to say that 40d silnylon is better for dry, sandy environments because it has a higher abrasion resistance, but 20d silpoly is better for wet climates because it doesn't absorb water and doesn't sag in the rain? For 2 more oz than the X-mid 1p (32. Oct 25, 2020 · I'm looking to buy a Thunderfly from Warbonnet and decided I would ideally like 20D silpoly with panel pulls. Actually, that's four out of five, but I'll let Meat Loaf do the selling on purchasing a SilPoly Superfly: Meatloaf to GingeGirl about SilPoly(cue the music, please) "Baby we can talk all night May 22, 2018 · I liked my silpoly tarps after a few trips, mostly dry weather, so I sold the nylon. But given that silpoly has the better UV resistance, there’s no reason to believe that it would fail quicker than silpoly. Most times you will see silnylon advertised in heavier weights from 30D-70D while silpoly is normally 15D-30D. Hoping to get some others input on what you have used. The MLD Monk Tarp (silpoly) is the best solo tarp IMO but just like tents most people nowadays want something wider. While 30D gives you a generous safety margin – the Akto has been used for some pretty hairy Arctic expeditions and came through OK. Silnylon: Key differences and considerations for backpackers. We have Gütermann Mara 70 thread in matching colors (brown/green)! Click here. . At that point it feels like its probably designed to be used with a footprint and then I start to wonder if the weight savings from thinner fabric are just erased by whatever you need to I have several Hammock and ground tarps in 30D SilNylon, and a Warbonnent ThunderFly in 20D SilPoly. 30D Ripstop Nylon 6. May 11, 2017 · Was wondering if WB has gotten the fabric in and started production on the second round of tarps using the 30d material like their site says. Mar 29, 2006 · Cependant je songe à changer de fournisseur pour mes tissus (afin de travailler avec des tissus 100% recyclés et sans PFCs), et envisage de fabriquer les toiles extérieures en silpoly 20D, silpoly 30D (poids légers et avantages du polyester) et silnylon 40D (pour ceux qui misent sur la durabilité avant tout). Rsbtr's 1. PU can peel, so if your aim somewhere at the nexus of longevity, weight, and cost, definitely go with silpoly. The question is 30D Silnylon or 20D Silpoly? The silpoly is an ounce lighter (18 oz. It compares favorably to my first generation Aeon Li in DCF, which weighs 550g/19. Mar 30, 2023 · 3: Some 20d silpolys are stronger than some 20d and even 30d silnylons. La résistance au vent et aux intempéries reste similaire. UV slowly destroys the material and soaks up more water. 4oz/yd. Silpoly is an ideal choice due to its longevity, low cost in comparison to other materials, and dependability. Not even in the same ballpark. 6oz, standard 75D: 25oz. Apr 2, 2015 · I've been tossing around the idea of making a version of the Silpoly suitable for floor material and I wanted to get some feedback. Look at the Canon 20D vs Canon 30D in our brand new Camera & Lens Size Comparison Tool. Jul 22, 2024 · I've had the Tents from the 1. May 28, 2019 · I use a WB Blackbird XLC. I've recently been doing a fair amount of MN winter camping with my trusty MJ tarp, which I lovebut last weekend it was SUPER windy and although my MJ held strong, I've decided I want a tarp with doors for added protection from the cold winter wind. The only current 30D silpoly tarps I know of are Warbonnet's. 5 oz/sq yd. Thread: 30D silnylon vs 20D Silpoly? Thread Tools. Three season tents used to be 70D a few decades ago but quickly went lighter to 30D and then over the past 20 years we've seen them settling in the range of 10-30D. nylon 6 vs nylon 6,6) and many formulations of poly (e. #memahami #kain #tenda #flysheet #silnylon #polyurethane #nylon #flysheetnylon #silpoly #pu3 20D is great stuff. If it was just a tarp, maybe the 15D 0. " But what you said about the Haven Tent isn't completely true. Our SilPoly is a 20D Ripstop Polyester with a silicone coating. It would be a more difficult choice if both options were 30d. Weights for just the fabric (and not including hood) are 4. New color looks great. Also, ProTrail canopy fabric is pressure rated at 5,000 mm. The standard version is 70D as well. Both are on sale until tomorrow for Aug 15, 2021 · It is the coating used on both sides of most of their silpoly fabrics, and I”ve had no noticeable problems with the 20D silpoly mentioned above. SilNylon is stronger (but by how much I do not know). It’s 17oz and smaller than the above tarps, but includes doors (which you’d normally tie-back in case you’re not familiar with doors on tarps). The 20D Silpoly ripstop fabric features a silicone/PU layer on each side for a completely waterproof, windproof finish with increased UV resistance. seller said they thought it was silnylon, but didnt seem confident. 20D silpoly PU 4000 by 10cm increments. As has been mentioned before, that ET 30d silpoly appears identical to Locus Gear’s 30d silnylon. I'd like to know what it really is then if it isn't 20D simply because that's what I wanted. NickTx. The RBTR 20D silpoly has as much if not more of a soft hand as a 30D silnylon. 5oz more. They are more durable and stretchier than the polyester tarps, meaning it could protect the floor 20d silpoly is definitely not 30d silnylon in terms of thickness or feel and I cannot imagine feeling comfortable using 10d silpoly and 7d silpoly as a floor. 5 oz (610g) would be my first choice. 1 oz Silpoly PU4000 (1. It weighs 1. 20D Silpoly is ideal for 3 season use in smaller shelters. it didn't really matter to me much when i bought it, but i'm thinking of selling it and would like to have an answer for prospective buyers. I do expect the 20D silpoly will not be quite as durable and strong as silcoated 6. g. 9oz for 40d. La toile est resté montée plusieurs fois en plein soleil durant plusieurs jours. Jun 2, 2019 · I use a WB Blackbird XLC. DCF is a cool fabric and can last a long time, but it's unlikely to be a longer lived material than a 20D silpoly canopy. I was wondering if anyone has a similar specifications sheet for 20D and/or 30D SilPoly? So far the closest thing I've found has been this Fabric Detail Sheet from Ripstop by the Roll for 30D Silnylon which is a different and less durable fabric than Silpoly, and it still doesn't list some properties I'm interested in like failure strength and Jun 21, 2022 · Looks like the new 20d silpoly fly is about 0. Jul 11, 2020 · @Fly Fishing Rick The website lists the material as "20D 2000MM NeverMist SilPoly" and my order states "20D SilPoly". They also make a 30D SilPoly tarps they call the Ground Tarp. 2. That UL 15D stuff is garbage. Only the XL version uses 210T as the body. The untreated fabric made from 20D nylon typically weighs less than 1 oz/sq. May 2, 2022 · It’s probably bulkier than some silpoly tarps, but with the two cuben tarps I really stopped shopping. 1 oz 20D silpoly, I'd just go with that. Punctures are easily mended, though, using DCF repair tape. I like it enough to have replaced both my nylon tarps with the same thing in poly. Szybka i sprawna realizacja zamówienia. Gatewood Cape uses 30D silnylon. Jun 12, 2017 · My foray into poly started off badly, but I'm giving it another shot with the heavier 20D. Whereas 20D is a good tent fabric, 75D polyester is more often used in clothing items. 6 oz Silpoly offers higher strength, lower bias stretch, and better puncture/abrasion resistance than our lightweight 1. 20d: fing schon bei 2kg an zu reißen und entgültig bei 3,5kg 30d: fing bei 7kg an und riss bei 8,2 kg komplett durch Was geht eigentlich bei dem 20d Stoff ab? Und ich hab daraus ein Zelt genäht 😑 Feb 11, 2023 · You can’t find 15D silnylon either, at least not in the States. You see how this plays out: no 20D polyester for anyone but fanatics (me). MLD supply the TrailStar in 20D silnylon, and that’s not exactly a wimpy shelter. Jun 4, 2017 · Silpoly 20D or 30D? By happydensity in forum Weather Protection Replies: 4 Last Post: 09-27-2017, 19:17. SlingFin doesn’t list the pressure rating but it is undoubtedly much lower. Coated. 93 oz membrane Silpoly would be worth it, but not for a poncho tarp. I quoted the case of the Stephenson WarmLite routinely surviving major storms with a 20d silnylon fly. I have a Superfly with the 20D silpoly. The only real difference I can tell is that xenon lists a hydrostatic head of 1000' while silpoly, I believe, is 1500. Warbonnet says the silpoly Mar 6, 2022 · In my opinion, sliders tend to wear out much more quickly on DCF tents than on silnylon or silpoly tents because DCF tents are high tension and therefore put a ton of stress on the zipper. The zipper failed long before the fabric, so even 20D silpoly is MORE than enough Before that I did the same thing with a bivy made up with 15D NON-Ripstop Silpoly, and even that held up fine in a range of conditions. 1/oz Sil/PU Polyester – Featuring 2nd generation of our silicone double coated 1. I feel both are strong enough to take whatever I throw at them. 1 osy nylon from DIY Gear Supply and the 20d calendared 1. 20D 2000mm NeverMist™ Silpoly: 62″ Roll/$9. My foray into poly started off badly, but I'm giving it another shot with the heavier 20D. 58r (where r is the radius of the 30D fabric). 9oz, lite 30D: 19. 5oz for 20d vs 7. In our tents we use 15-20D woven fabrics which are fairly normal for a lightweight tent. 10 vs 20 vs 30D) and the coatings (e. Price per meter. I was happy with both and would use either again. Sep 14, 2011 · • Un tipi en silpoly 20D, ayant une vingtaine de nuits d'utilisation • Un tipi en silnylon/PU 30D ayant une grosse centaine de nuits d'utilisation en amérique du sud. For reference, I have had two SilPoly shelters I have used recently a long with 3 nylon variants, and one DCF . Oct 10, 2016 · It is mostly design. DCF is claimed to have the "highest tear and tensile strength of any competing fabric on a weight-by-weight and thickness basis. Jun 5, 2023 · MLD Supertarp is no doubt supreme in terms of material and build. The stretch of nylon gives it additional strength and in the usage of a lightweight tent, the practical difference is usually adjusting the pole slightly which takes a few second at max. SilPoly is "lighter, tighter, can handle an all-nighter" (when raining) - as well as UV resistant. This material offers weight savings, lower moisture adsorption, lower sag when wet, and slightly better UV resistance compared to silicone-coated nylon. Because of characteristics very suitable for tarps, tents, pack covers and other rain gear. e. Jan 22, 2025 · Silpoly is marketed as having less stretch and better UV resistance. Jul 9, 2018 · There is not much difference if any in price that I have ever noticed between the two materials if the same weights are compared. Silpoly 30D +++ non >3. Oct 29, 2020 · Given the choice between 20D silpoly and 30D silnylon for the same price I went with the poly for all the benefits at the risk of it possibly not lasting as long. I'd love to hear from some of y'all that have used silpoly gear with success long term, I'd like to hear about long term durability and how well it holds it's waterproofing in Jan 10, 2020 · Silpoly Vs. 5: Some/Most of the 20d silpoly and 20d silnylon availble to DYI’ers though resellers are not as good as the ones used by some tent manufacturers. Dacron 55, Dacron Memahami jenis kain flysheet dan istilah yang sering kita dengar. but the coating is not as good either. Following along to see what’s new with suspensions. Jan 20, 2025 · 皆さまこんにちは。株式会社プラグフラックスの小森です。年が明け、寒い日が続きますが風邪など引いてないでしょうか？今回のブログでは寒い雪山から暖かい季節まで1年中大活躍のLITEWAYフロアレスシェルターを取り上げ、シェルターを構成する生地の比較をしたいと思います！お気づきの Feb 27, 2017 · My foray into poly started off badly, but I'm giving it another shot with the heavier 20D. Oct 6, 2024 · Ich dachte mehr oder weniger dasselbe, aber Xavier konnte das Verhalten von Silnylon 20D im Vergleich zu Silpoly 30D in Bezug auf die Wasseraufnahme testen. Par temps humide, le silnylon pourra légèrement se détendre. 1 oz silnylon or silpoly. It’s been about five years, but I think the 20d may have been a little softer and more supple than the 30d. By Monkeyboy42 in forum Ripstop By The Roll Air pads: This one feels the riskiest to me. Most all of the specs / product descriptions have been updated to note 20d vs 30d. I had a 2017 notch which was 3-4oz lighter, which was very compelling. Examples: ultralite 20D: 15. Dec 2, 2012 · With a good silpoly, there isn't a big strength difference (nothing like accountant vs elite athlete). No 10D or 15D silnylons to be found anywhere though. And it weight about 1. And for space the X-Mid is quite a bit more generous with 92" x 50" floor (vs 81" x 48/42"), more headroom from a longer ridgelilne, and much larger vestibules. 3oz/yd 2 per spec btw. May 12, 2023 · Brilliant on Henry’s part to offer both fly options, TT’s IG page mentions 30D silnylon being a better choice for “higher elevations or shoulder season”. But after some decent rain this past weekend, I'm worried I jumped the gun on the poly. When inspecting the tent for manufacturing quality, we were impressed by the overall stitching quality and feel of the tent. 4 oz (later ones weigh only 490g), while costing less and probably offering greater protection, increased durability, and lower environmental footprint. Sil-Poly also has lower tear and puncture resistance comparatively to our 6. Jun 7, 2019 · The more robust and WP sil/poly from RBTR is 20D PU 4000, which is 1. 20D Polyester, DWR Feb 20, 2018 · I've recently been doing a fair amount of MN winter camping with my trusty MJ tarp, which I lovebut last weekend it was SUPER windy and although my MJ held strong, I've decided I want a tarp with doors for added protection from the cold winter wind. Then you have some companies offering silnylon in a 20d version. Apr 2, 2023 · Xavier was able to test the behavior of the 20D silnylon compared to the 30D silpoly concerning water absorption. Silpoly Disadvantages: One of the disadvantages of Silpoly is also its reduced stretch, which demands more precise pitching, especially in uneven terrain. My dog stepped on my old Golite tipi and put a 30" rip in it. Best used when you prefer a more robust material over the absolute lightest weight. DuoMid and larger Mids are for now still 30d only. I think a lot of the issues are with stitch hole elongation on the reinforcement panels. They are more durable and stretchier than the polyester tarps, meaning it could protect the floor Jan 2, 2021 · Then there is the question of whether losing the nylon for a slight weight penalty creates other types of penalties; such as loss of packability, bias stretch, or abrasion, puncture and tear resistance. Go with the hybrid here maybe to avoid a disaster blowout? Basically on the extreme light end here you can save 6oz+2oz+10oz = a little over a pound. I believe the SilPoly to be a superior material for tarps. Groundsheets are under different stresses than a shelter, and I think either option would work as one. Piotr Linek. Don’t see much weight savings there, compared to 7-15D fabric. Silpoly is not necessarily lighterthe 30d silpoly the next batch of our camo is made from will be about 1. Getting the WB Thunderfly and considering the 20D vs 30D. Lanshans use a much more substantial floor. View Profile View Forum Posts View Articles I think the bigger difference ere is 30d vs 20d, and it's an obvious no brainier to go with the higher denier for a winter specific shelter. 8 oz for xmid): - Rectangular shape, 4-stake pitch, smaller footprint - 20D silpoly (Floor is 30D sil-nylon) - Might be roomier compared to the X-Mid 1p? I know this a sticking point for some who have moved to larger tents simply because of the inner from the 1p. Ripstop SilPoly+PU 20D Bizon. Also, it seems that the needle holes don't close up as well, and that it's easier for the water to get through the (un-sealed) panel pulls. Szczerze polecam. Less prone to misting), but others may correct me. 000mm / >7 DaN. Durability – If you are looking for something tough and rugged that is only going to be used as a groundsheet, then perhaps you would be better off with a nylon based tarp. 7D MTN 6. After a bit more testing in big wind, we may offer the DM, DMXL and Super in Pro 20d too- maybe next year. Dec 25, 2020 · I recently received a new Bushwack Thunderfly and when I weighed it today it is 13. I'd love a bushwack superfly, but the 20d fabric has me quite hesitant to its durability. Ridgeline: 13 feet; Width: 103 inches; Weight: 16. Ein äußerst interessantes Experiment. So on balance, I suspect that Jon is right and silpoly is the greener fabric. The above tarps are 20D SilPoly. ET’s 30d silpoly is about the same weight as MLD’s 20d silnylon (~1. 20D Polyester with Nano-Ripstop Grid 5000mm+ Hydrostatic Head 100% Silicone Coated, Both Sides ~1. Now, one advantage to SilPoly is that sand and dirt do not stick to the coating as much . Oct 9, 2017 · First attempt at a large sized project using the above and it seems pretty maddening trying to get accurate measurements. 1 20D already weighs 1. 00 FABRIC & COLOR: CUSTOM MOUNTAINFLY × 1 FWIW, the sag some make a big deal about when silny is wet compared to DCF(out of your price range) and silpoly can be avoided by integrating a short bungeed/shock cord section into tie outs. Dec 2, 2022 · Silpoly textiles are ideal for creating a waterproof membrane for tents, tarps, and other camping shelters. Polyester is stiffer than nylon, so less forgiving in pitching. 3 after). ) and is said to pick up less water weight than the nylon. 9 oz) silpoly is available but it’s pretty weak stuff. yard whereas 75D polyester weighs around 2 oz per sqare yard. But does it also pack twice as big? Is there any other glaring reason as to why someone who is very budget conscious should spend the extra money on silnylon over 70D urethane coated nylon when making a DIY tarp? Mar 11, 2023 · Siliconized nylon, more commonly called silnylon, is a waterproof fabric used to make tents by many smaller manufacturers including Tarptent, Mountain Laurel Designs, and Hilleberg which specialize in making ultralight backpacking gear or expedition-grade tents. 20D silpoly fly weighs about 0. The video below is a BOTE, unscientific test for sure, but I think it illustrates the point: Jan 17, 2018 · Material: 20D 2000mm NeverMist™ Silpoly Note: Also available in 30D (thicker, more durable) fabric for minor additional weight addition (~2oz) Brand: Warbonnet Outdoors; Weight: 18 oz (tarp only) Dimensions: 11′ (ridgeline) x 10′ width; Packed Size: In stuff sack: ~ 13 inches x 6 inches x 4 inches; MSRP: $140 Apr 22, 2016 · Cuben’s out of the question due to price. The weight savings for 20d is highly tempting but how durable is it? The poncho in particular I’m concerned with snagging. 0′ Width:103″ Ridgeline Length: 13’0” 30D 2000mm NeverMist™ Silnylon: 16. A buddies 20D shelter was just touched by a small tree limb and ripped. This is very similar to SilNylon but the polyester coating on the fabric gives it a different feel as well as increased durability. Available in our 20d and 30d SilPoly tarp fabrics. I think that 30D they use is a great fabric for what we do. silpoly: So, what's the big difference anyway? Silpoly has become tremendously popular mainly because it stays taut under load. Aug 28, 2020 · A good 20D is probably OK for 3+ season conditions provided the shelter is well designed. 8'x9') - Xenon 20d ripstop silpoly is low stretch and doesn't sag in the rain - Flat tarps provide nearly unlimited different set-up options - Ties outs at each corner and at mid-points, 8 total - Bivy mitten hooks at ridge ends Jan 6, 2020 · Tipik comme Liteway (utilise du silpoly 20D, c'est un peu moins solide que du silnylon 20D (l'équivalent en résistance du silnylon 20D serait le silpoly 30D si on en croit les chiffres d'ET - c'est le tissus de la SMD Lunar Solo). ynqwniyt dsb esewnqqd zxse igkwuz nerwwc teaze bklfcc wxza ckof